There is a lot of bad advice being spread around concerning self defense these days. One of the worst and most dangerous pieces of bad advise is to run when faced with a knife-wielding attacker.
The supposed reason for this advise is that it is very difficult to successfully defend yourself against a knife attack without being cut in the process. Ok, that may be true, but “running away from the problem” rarely helps in any situaion, especially when you are in imminent danger!
To dispel this myth, I usually use a very graphic demonstration in my training. I take one of my students, usually one of those who recommend running from a knife fight and, while holding a knife for him or her to see, I tell him to respond. As the more experienced of you might be able to imagine, I only need to take one or two steps before I’m holding my fleeing victim by the shirt or, even better, the hair and I’m repeatedly stabbing him or her in the back and later in the neck after he or she falls, which they always seem to do.
The “dead” victim usually responds by saying: “Yeah, but its better than doing nothing!”
“Listen, turning your back to an armed attacker who is standing so close to you that you don’t have any chance of getting away IS doing nothing! No, you don’t have a 100 % chance of surviving uninjured, but if you turn your back to him and do nothing you have a zero percent chance of surviving!”
So what should you do when facing an edged weapon attack?
Why don’t we see if we can even the odds a bit.
First of all, why is a knife attack so dangerous? Because an attacker armed with a knife can badly injure or kill you quickly and easily.
Well, what would happen if you were to take one of your fingers and force it between his eyeball and eye socket? What would happen if you would crush his windpipe? What would happen if you would kick him in the knee and tear the ligaments and tendons that support his leg?
It sounds to me that you could very easily kill or injure a person without a knife, which would make you almost as dangerous as him, if you know how to fight!
Should I tell you what is the real reason why most attempted knife attacks are successful? Its because the attacker distracts his victim and hides the knife until he’s been able to stab him at least once or twice!
That means that a person who has been trained in situational awareness and reading body language to recognize a potential knife attack would have the opportunity to launch a pre-emptive attack upon the knife attacker before he completed drawing his weapon and, if he didn’t even have a chance to draw his knife before you took him out, there would have been no difference between taking the would-be knife attacker out and defending yourself against a normal, unarmed opponent!
The bottom line is that a knife attack is always a very bad situation to be in, but to try to run from it is like standing in the middle of a street and trying to outrun a car that is speeding in your direction–run left, run right, but don’t try to outrun a car, when you know you won’t have any chance of surviving that way!
And the sooner you see the car coming, the better your chances of surviving will be.


Follow me on Twitter